Page 6, Invasive Plants at Home, 11/3/22.Kindly contact, Kathy Connolly, 860-510-2136, Kathy@SpeakingofLandscapes.com
The drawbacks of cardboard are several, however. First, cardboard deprives the underlying soil of moisture
and air exchange. This deprives the roots of desirable trees and shrubs of water and air. (Keep in mind that
tree and shrub roots extend horizontally well beyond their canopies.) Second, it alters soil microbial
populations. Microbial communities are likely to rebound after the smother is removed, but existing trees and
shrubs may suffer.
Additionally, cardboard products are not alike. Some are treated with chemicals; some incorporate
non-paper materials. Under certain circumstances, cardboard can harbor pests such as termites. Never
place cardboard directly against a building. If the cardboard has tape or staples, remove them. (Hint:
Before applying the cardboard, leave it in the rain to loosen the tape.)
WeedGuard or other weed-suppression papers: (https://www.weedguardplus.com/landscape)
Organic farmers use weed-suppressing cellulose fiber paper. WeedGuard is probably the best-known
brand. It is a useful replacement for dumpster cardboard, in that it is quality-controlled for soil safety.
It is easy to apply and can be used under straw. However, its drawback is that it decomposes in one
growing season. WeedGuard Red reportedly has slower decay times.
Newsprint is generally considered safe, but it needs to be 3” to 6” thick to create an effective smother.
Ram board is another option. This material is used to protect floors during painting and construction. It
sold at building and paint supplies stores. Ram board is recycled cardboard; it is much heavier than
WeedGuard. Ram board is described as "breathable," but this benefit may not extend to landscape
use. Rain, snow, and mulch particles may quickly alter its air exchange capabilities. Ram board is easy
and quick to apply; it can greatly reduce labor.
[i] Metal mesh over Japanese Knotweed: Invented in the UK, this method places hardware cloth over
knotweed patches. Knotweed grows through it and essentially strangles itself. See
https://www.jksl.com/japanese-knotweed-treatment/meshtech-removal/. (While this method is used in the
UK, it is new in the US, and research results are lacking. I have contacted several researchers who, so far, can
only say that "the jury is out.”)
[j] Organic Herbicide: This group of herbicides has benefits, but a few drawbacks. Most organic herbicides
dissipate quickly after application compared to some synthetic herbicides. They avoid the use of persistent
chemicals that are toxic to bees and other pollinators.
"Organic" does not mean harmless, however. When misapplied, some organic herbicides can harm pollinators
as well as people. Always read the label, determine the time of day and time of year when the product is best
applied, and mix according to instructions for the target vegetation. The instructions may also provide
information about potential impact to aquatic life, pollinators, mammals, and other creatures. The material
safety data sheet (MSDS, found online at the manufacturer's website) provides advice on protection for eyes
and skin. Organic products are evolving, and new products become registered for sale every year. Check for
new products at sites such as OMRI.org. (Search for "herbicides.")