Updated: 2/13/2023 5 of 10 PHILMONT SCOUT RANCH |PHILMONT COOKING METHODS
Boil in Turkey/Ziploc Bags – PROHIBITED
Considerations/Reasoning: Plastic bags cannot be easily cleaned and therefore introduce a large amount of
unnecessary smellable plastic waste (which overloads already overstrained backcountry trash collection).
They also may lead to melting/leeching of plastic and are difficult to safely retrieve from hot water.
Integrated Canister Stove (Jetboil, MSR Windburner systems, etc.) – Not Practical as Primary Stove
Considerations/Reasoning: Integrated canister stove systems can be a great supplemental stove for quickly
heating up enough water for hot drinks or preparing meals for those with strict dietary restrictions while also
serving as an emergency backup if the primary stoves fail. However, the integrated pot/cup cannot heat
enough water for the rehydration of a full crew’s food, requiring multiple boils or crew not being able to eat
at the same time. Pouring multiple batches of water from an integrated canister stove into the 8L pot causes
significant drops in water temperature which eliminates the ability to sanitize dishes. Not to mention these
repeated boils require constant engagement that could be diverted to other kitchen tasks by the cooks. The
utilization of adaptors leads to an extremely unstable stove surface for any size of pot to boil water safely.
Additionally, overfilled vessels can boil over onto the control/shut-off leading to scalds/burns. 1-2 liquid fuel
or isobutane canister stoves with a low, wide base split between the crew will end up being lighter and more
compact than integrated canister stoves.
Ultra-Compact Canister Stoves (MSR PocketRocket, SnowPeak GigaPower, BRS-3000T, GSI Pinnacle, etc.) – Not
Practical as Primary Stove
Considerations/Reasoning: Similar to integrated canister stoves, compact canister stoves can be a
supplemental stove when carefully paired with a SMALL lightweight pot or metal mug for hot drinks or
separate preparation of meals for those with strict dietary restrictions. It can also be a backup in case of the
failure of the primary low, stable, full-size stove. However, when these stoves are placed on top of a fuel
canister they are not a stable platform to boil the large quantities of water required for a crew of 8-12.
Additionally, the control/shut-off is generally located under a hot pot of boiling water, which can lead to
scalds and burns. 1-2 large, stable stoves, split between a crew of 8-12 is typically lighter than 4-6
ultracompact stoves.
Alternative Fuel Stoves (alcohol, solid fuel, or natural fiber) – PROHIBITED
Considerations/Reasoning: Stoves which utilize alcohol, solid fuel, or natural fiber (wood, etc.) are prohibited
for use at Philmont. During fire bans, which happen often in the high desert of New Mexico, only canister and
liquid fuel stoves are permitted to be used on most USFS, state, and private land. Additionally, these stoves
utilize advanced techniques beyond what is taught at Philmont, they lack the ability to be turned off when
needed, they often lack the power to boil water in a 6-8-quart pot, and the wide variety of fuels cannot be
readily provided at Philmont backcountry camps/commissaries (only white gas and canister fuel are readily
available in these locations).
Utilizing Bleach Instead of Boiling to Sanitize Dishware – PROHIBITED
Considerations/Reasoning: Bleach is typically utilized in the BSA’s Three Pot Method to sanitize dishes,
cookware, and eating utensils in a front-country environment by many BSA Units. Commercial food service
operations also may use bleach or other chemical sanitizers. However, utilizing bleach as a sanitizer creates a
large quantity of spent grey water which then needs to be safely disposed of. In a backcountry setting like